On Facebook I came across a book review of a shamanic tools book. The reviewer said:
Another aspect of the book I find problematic is that Native American concepts, terminology and ceremonies feature prominently throughout it, with no attempt whatsoever to address the question of cultural appropriation. A gathering of the Lakota, Nakota and Dakota peoples more than twenty years ago declared war on non-Native New Agers who ‘steal’ Native American spirituality and sell it for profit, and many other Native Americans equally strongly oppose what they see as the ultimate act of theft committed against their people.
This started to get my brain thinking about my own shamanic traditions. Where do my traditions and shamanic skills come from? Am I guilty of stealing other traditions or have I learnt from those who have? It also concerned me in terms of being true to the shamanic / spiritual calling. So here are my personal thoughts.
Firstly I’m english. I’ve done work on tracing my ancestors through the generations – from this I know that we are all english to at least 5 generations and all the ancestors back to the 17th century are english. Most of them were born / lived in Lincolnshire. Interestingly one of my uncle found a grave in a local church of a monk( de redding) who was priest to one of the norman knights who has the same surname as my paternal grandmothers family. So I suspect that there is some norman blood in me. On the normans Wikipedia states :
The Normans (French: Normands; Latin: Nortmanni) were the people who in the 10th and 11th centuries gave their name to Normandy, a region in France. They were originally Viking raiders and pirates from Denmark, Norway and Iceland, who under their leader Rollo agreed to swear fealty to King Charles III of West Francia.[1] Through generations of assimilation and mixing with the native Frankish and Roman-Gaulish populations, the Northmen’s descendants (“Norman” comes from “Norseman“)[2] would gradually merge with the Carolingian-based cultures of West Francia.[3] The distinct cultural and ethnic identity of the Normans emerged initially in the first half of the 10th century, and it continued to evolve over the succeeding centuries.[4]
……..
The descendants of Rollo and his warriors replaced the Norse religion and Old Norse language with Catholicism (Christianity) and the Gallo-Romance language of the local people, blending maternal Frankish heritage and Old Norse tradition and custom to synthesize a unique “Norman” culture in the north of France.[7] The Norman language was forged by the adoption of the indigenous langue d’oïl branch of Romance by a Norse-speaking ruling class, and it developed into the regional language that survives today.[1]
So my lineage would partly come from the vikings and the fusion of the old norse tradition into christianity.This is quite an extrapolation but seems to be the best I can do with the information I’ve got.It does make me more interested in exploring the old norse traditions from a shamanic traditions perspective.
Secondly, in terms of what I have learnt about shamanic practice. It has come from a mixture of books and teachings from the Sacred Trust (Simon Buxton). Much of this has been based on the work of Michael Harner and the Foundation of Shamanic Studies. Michael Harner’s anthropological approach does take different elements from different indigenous populations to create a western version. The work and training I have done includes this and other more local traditions ( for more details read Simon Buxton’s book on the Shamanic Way of the Bee, which I have experienced some parts of). I came across an interesting article on modern shamanic practice by Annette Høst which goes into details of the different names to call the newer tradition. She starts:
I am standing with both feet in my own time and soil and society. Trying to learn things that were forgotten and forbidden for a long time. Then some people come and call me names. Or they call what I do names. I think you know the situation.
Depending on if they are anthropologists or Christians, or Americans or new age booksellers they call what we practise for neo shamanism, core shamanism or urban shamanism or something else. But none of those names or labels seems to sit really right. This makes me ask: What is really characteristic of our shamanic practice here and now, of our shamanic tradition? And which name or label would fit?
This comes to the crux of the question for me. I want to be honest and truthful about myself and my spiritual practice to myself and to others. Labels are a way to communicate things to others but place a limit on who were are and what we do, that’s not always helpful. A label doesn’t inform anyone about the spiritual relationship of that person. I appreciate this makes it difficult for someone trying to find a “Shaman” in our western culture. When I use the label “Doctor” it is clear that I went to medical school and am trained in the ways of western medicine (or have a PhD). Spiritual practice is different as it goes beyond intellectual understanding. Undertaking my current 3 year shamanic practitioner training teaches me how to use different skills and at the end may give an indication that I can use these skills. The validity of any information or healing someone receives through me, has to be tested by them so that they are sure it is right for them.
Ultimately this is a spiritual practice that is led by a direct relationship with spirit. No-one can own revelations from Spirit. How we are taught things by spirit will vary from direct revelation to being taught by others. Shamanism is a living breathing practice that adapts and changes. I would expect shamanism practiced in a western culture to be different to that of an indigenous population because the culture is different. I would expect shamanic practice today to be different to that of old traditions because society is different. The principle here is that shamanism relates to the individual and is not set in stone. This is why it is a spiritual practice based on accessing the spiritual realm through altered states of consciousness. It is open to ongoing revelation and development by the individual that reflects the individual’s ongoing relationship with spirit. There will be diversity on how shamanism is practice because each practitioner will have their own relationship with spirit.
So for me this is about integrity within the spiritual work that I do. It is being honest about my shamanic traditions and the work that I do. It is then up to those who may wish to work with me to decide if I am what they are looking for.
Much love and blessings